🧠 Stop Annoying Your Visitors and Create Pop-Ups That ACTUALLY Work

Welcome back to the 55th edition of Nord Media

The other day, I was reminiscing with an old friend about those scrappy college jobs we all had. 

I told him about my time as a dishwasher in high school.

Endless stacks of plates, soaked shoes, and the constant buzz of the kitchen. 

He laughed and said his gig at a coffee shop wasn’t much better.

Crowds that never stopped, the smell of coffee permanently stuck to his clothes, and the chaos of keeping up during the morning rush.

But then he said something that kinda stuck with me…

The one part of the job he actually enjoyed was writing on the chalkboard outside. 

Every morning, he’d come up with a clever message. If it were dull or off, people would walk right by. 

But on the days he popped off, suddenly, people stopped, smiled, and came inside.

That got me thinking—pop-ups are kind of like that chalkboard. 

When done right, they catch someone’s attention, make them pause, and invite them to take action. 

Done wrong, they’re easy to ignore—or worse, they annoy.

So today, I’m breaking down exactly how to create the perfect pop-up that works and, better yet, convert.

Let’s get into it.

Contextual Timing

Pop-ups are designed to be disruptive.

That’s the point—they grab attention. 

But with great disruption comes great responsibility.

If your pop-up shows up at the wrong moment, it’s like someone interrupting you mid-sentence or barging into a room uninvited. 

Annoying, right? 

Now think about your website visitors. 

Do you really want your pop-up to be that guy?

Timing is everything. 

Pop-ups should feel like they belong—like they’re showing up at the exact moment your visitor needs them. Ask yourself:

• Are you giving visitors enough time to explore before the pop-up appears? If it’s the second they land, they’re likely to close it without even looking.

• Does it align with their intent? Are they about to leave, or are they still engaging with your content?

• Are you considering their journey? What page are they on? What action are they likely to take next?

For example, an exit-intent pop-up can work wonders because it shows up when someone’s already decided to leave. 

It’s a last-second pitch, not an interruption. 

On the other hand, a discount offer might work best after someone spends a few minutes browsing your product pages—it feels like a reward, not a random intrusion.

Your pop-up should feel helpful, not pushy. 

It should say, “Hey, I noticed you’re here, and I’ve got something you might love,” instead of, 

“LOOK AT ME NOW!”

Next time you’re setting up a pop-up, take a second to think about the timing.

Is it adding to the experience, or is it just getting in the way?

Provide Value

Nobody gives away their email address just for fun. 

If you’re asking someone to sign up, fill out a form, or make a purchase, you need to make it worth their time. 

What’s in it for them?

Your pop-up is about them. 

What problem are you solving, or what reward are you offering that makes taking action a no-brainer? 

• Is it a discount?

• A free trial?

• Exclusive content they can’t get anywhere else?

Put yourself in their shoes. Would you stop scrolling for what you’re offering?

 If the answer isn’t a resounding “yes,” then it’s time to rethink.

Here’s how you can level up your value proposition:

1. Be Specific
   Instead of a generic “Sign up for our newsletter,” spell out exactly what they’re getting. For example:

“Get 15% off your first purchase when you subscribe. Offer ends [specific date].”

“Sign up now and get two months of [product/service] completely free!”

2. Highlight Exclusivity
   Make it feel special like it’s something they can’t afford to miss.

“Join our VIP list and be the first to access our limited-edition products.”

“Subscribe for insider tips and strategies we only share with our email community.”

3. Connect to Their Interests
   If your audience values connection or impact, tie your offer to that.

“Keep up with our latest non-profit events and see how you’re making a difference.”

“Be the first to know about our upcoming sustainability initiatives.”

4. Add a Sense of Urgency
   Pop-ups thrive on urgency. Give them a reason to act now.

“Sign up today and get free shipping—but only until midnight.”

“Hurry! Your 20% discount expires in [countdown timer].”

The goal is simple: 

Make the value so clear, so compelling, and so tangible that they can’t help but say yes.

Make Your Pop-Ups Mobily-Friendly

Your audience is most likely on their phones. 

Studies show that 42% of Ecom traffic now comes from mobile devices, and that number is only growing. 

If your pop-ups aren’t optimized for mobile, you’re going to have to get to work.

On mobile, you’re working with limited real estate. 

A pop-up that looks fine on a desktop can easily overwhelm or frustrate users on a smaller screen. 

Mobile pop-ups need to be clean, simple, and laser-focused on your message.

Readable Text

Keep your font size large enough to read without pinching and zooming. 

Clear and concise messaging is key—get to the point quickly.

Minimalist Design 

Avoid clutter.

 Use whitespace strategically to make your pop-up easy to navigate and visually appealing.

Big, Easy-to-Tap Buttons 

Ensure your call-to-action (CTA) buttons are large enough to tap without accidentally hitting the wrong thing. 

Bonus points if the button color contrasts with the rest of the design.

Smart Timing and Placement 

Avoid interrupting visitors as soon as they land. 

Trigger pop-ups at the right moment—like after scrolling or when they show intent to leave.

Don’t Forget Responsiveness

Your pop-ups should automatically adjust to fit any screen size. 

From a tiny smartphone to a larger tablet, they need to look sharp and function seamlessly.

Mobile users expect a frictionless experience. 

If your pop-ups aren’t optimized for their screens, they’ll close them faster than you can say “conversion.”

A/B Test Your Pop-Ups

No matter how confident you are in your design, copy, or offer, you’re guessing until you test it. 

Look for pop-up software that makes A/B testing simple. Some tools let you easily create multiple versions of your pop-ups, so you can test things like:

• Offers (discounts vs. free shipping)

• Headlines and copy

• Colors and visuals

• Timing and triggers

Do your research based on your needs.

Once you start testing, you’ll quickly see patterns emerge. 

Use those insights to refine your pop-ups and apply what you’ve learned to future campaigns. 

The more you test, the more dialed-in your strategy becomes—and the more conversions you’ll drive.

A/B testing will ultimately help you build a playbook of what works for your audience so you can keep improving with every campaign.

So no more guessing games in 2025.

Closing Thoughts

Pop-ups might seem like a small part of your marketing strategy, but when done right, they can be a game-changer. 

Don’t just slap a message on the screen and hope for the best.

Your pop-ups are like your digital storefront chalkboard. 

They can invite people in, make them pause, and ultimately drive action. 

But to make that happen, you’ve got to put in the work—optimize for timing, focus on mobile usability, and never stop testing.

So, as you set up your next campaign, ask yourself:

• Is this pop-up adding to my customer’s experience?

• Am I offering real value?

• Have I tested it enough to know what works best?

With the right approach, you’ll not only boost your conversions—you’ll leave a lasting impression on your audience.

Thanks for reading, and as always, I’d love to hear what you think. 

Let me know what’s worked (or hasn’t) for your pop-ups. 

Your feedback is what makes these newsletters better every week. 

Additional Content Brought to You By:

Unlock the full potential of your workday with cutting-edge AI strategies and actionable insights, empowering you to achieve unparalleled excellence in the future of work. Download the free guide today!

Connect with me on social 👇
LinkedIn • Instagram • Twitter 

Thank you for reading! I appreciate you.

Sincerely,
Kody