Stop Letting Your 3PL Sabotage Customer Experience...

Before we get started, is there anything specific you want to learn about? Let me know, as always, I appreciate all of you who reply each week and share feedback with me.

Imagine this… your 3PL sends impressive monthly reports. 

99% order accuracy, 98.2% on-time shipping, perfect inventory levels. 

Meanwhile, your customer service team is overwhelmed with complaints about wrong products, damaged packages, and delayed orders. 

Your 3PL is measuring the wrong things…

They track metrics that make operations look good while ignoring fulfillment factors that determine whether customers return. 

And it’s shown that 16% of shoppers abandon retailers after one incorrect delivery, while 69% won't even shop again if delivery is late. 

In this email, we're breaking down: 

• The hidden fulfillment metrics that directly impact customer retention 

• How to audit your 3PL's real performance using data they don't provide 

• The accountability framework that protects your customer experience 

Let’s dive in:

Over 10,000 small businesses are targeted annually for ADA violations…

Facing $10,000+ in settlements and legal fees. 

Traditional accessibility overlays solve fewer than 30% of violations, interfere with assistive technologies, and slow your site down.

Patrol is the only Shopify platform that fixes accessibility issues directly in your theme code, automating manual audits, testing, and remediation - making your store more ADA compliant WITHOUT slowing performance.

Shopify Merchant’s trust Patrol to:

• Automatically audit and resolve compliance issues.
  

• Provide continuous monitoring for new violations.
  

• Ensure protection without costly developers.
  

Avoid expensive compliance headaches and lawsuits.

Start Your Free Compliance Audit →

The Hidden Metrics That Kill Customer Retention 

Your 3PL's monthly reports show the basics: shipped on time, inventory levels, return rates… 

But they're missing the metrics that actually predict customer behavior. 

• Pick Accuracy Beyond Order Accuracy 

Industry standard varies wildly, elite 3PLs achieve 99.9% accuracy while others accept error rates up to 4% (meaning 96% accuracy). 

Here's the problem: a single wrong item can trigger returns, refunds, and lost customers forever. 

So, set 99.9% accuracy as your minimum standard.

• Same-Day Processing Windows

Your 3PL might ship "on time" but miss critical processing deadlines that impact customer experience. 

Orders placed before the cutoff should process the same day, not sit in the queue for 24-48 hours before fulfillment begins. 

• Damage Rates and Packaging Quality

20% of orders result in damaged or broken goods, but most 3PLs don't track packaging-related damage separately from carrier damage. 

When customers receive broken products, they blame your brand, not the shipping company. 

• Returns Processing Speed

Standard return processing is 48-72 hours for 95% of returns. 

Slower processing creates inventory accuracy issues and delays refunds, directly impacting customer satisfaction and repeat purchase likelihood. Your 3PL's self-reported metrics tell one story… your actual customer experience data tells another. 

• Order Tracking Data Analysis

Pull shipping data directly from carriers and compare against 3PL reports. 

Look for discrepancies in pickup times, processing delays, and delivery performance that don't show up in standard reports. 

• Customer Service Ticket Patterns

Analyze support tickets by fulfillment-related issues: wrong items, damaged goods, missing products, and delayed shipping notifications.

Track these by volume and resolution time to identify systemic 3PL problems. 

• Shipping Analytics Deep Dive

Monitor the carrier performance at the 3PL facility. 

Are certain locations consistently performing worse? Are damage rates higher from specific warehouses? 

This reveals operational issues your 3PL might not disclose. 

• Return Data Correlation

Cross-reference return reasons with 3PL performance. 

High return rates for "wrong item" or "damaged packaging" indicate fulfillment problems, not product issues.

The 3PL Accountability Framework 

Instead of accepting industry standard performance, build accountability systems that protect customer experience like this: 

• SLA Requirements That Matter

Set order accuracy minimums at 99.95%, not 99%. 

Require same-day processing for orders placed before designated cutoffs, and establish damage rate thresholds with financial penalties for excess breakage. 

• Performance Monitoring Systems

Implement real-time tracking for order processing stages. 

Monitor pick accuracy at the SKU level, not just the order level. 

Track packaging quality through customer feedback and damage claims. 

• Backup Fulfillment Strategies 

Identify alternative 3PL partners for peak periods when your primary partner historically underperforms. 

Maintain inventory splits across multiple facilities to prevent stockouts during high-volume periods. 

• Escalation Protocols 

Create automatic alerts when performance drops below thresholds. 

Establish clear communication channels for addressing issues before they impact customer experience. 

Brands using comprehensive 3PL monitoring report 25-40% fewer fulfillment-related customer service issues and significantly higher repeat purchase rates because they catch problems before customers experience them.

Superfiliate empowers brands to run end-to-end influencer, affiliate, and referral programs by providing a comprehensive, user-friendly platform that consolidates multiple word-of-mouth channels.

With features including cobranded landing pages, social listening, and product seeding, start building genuine, long-term partnerships with creators while leveraging data-driven insights from integrations with Meta and TikTok to optimize performance.

Superfiliate enables marketers to prove their value, make informed decisions, and unlock the full potential of their influencer and affiliate programs.

Superfiliate recently launched their Automations Engine that is a suite of tools that puts the most time-consuming parts of running an influencer, affiliate, and ambassador program on autopilot via a beautiful flow builder.

Want to send a program invite via DMs to every creator with 10k-20k followers that tags you in an Instagram story? We have an automation for that.

Email marketers have email and SMS flows, well, now influencer marketers have flows of their own!

One brand saved over 166 hours in July along with their influencer management automations.

My favorite part is that it's multi-channel, just like your interactions with creators and partners. » Check it Out Today «

Final Thoughts

Your 3PL's performance directly impacts customer lifetime value, but most brands only monitor surface-level metrics. 

The hidden fulfillment factors like pick accuracy, processing speed, packaging quality, and return handling, determine whether customers trust your brand enough to order again. 

Start auditing the metrics your 3PL doesn't want to report. 

Your customer retention depends on it.

Want to learn more? Connect with me on social 👇
Twitter - LinkedIn - Instagram - Threads

Thank you for reading! I appreciate you.

Until Next Time ✌️
- Kody

Disclaimer: Special thanks to Patrol & Superfiliate for sponsoring today’s newsletter.