- Nord Media
- Posts
- You are the premium option. Act Like It.
You are the premium option. Act Like It.
Your pricing needs to feel like a win, not a risk.
Kody Nordquist
May 22, 2025
Welcome back to the 108th edition of Nord Media
Most of you probably have insanely good offers.
Like… “why wouldn’t someone say yes?” type of good.
But then you drop your pricing… and suddenly it’s:
“I’ll think about it.”
Price itself is rarely the issue.
It’s how you present the price.
People don’t evaluate offers logically. They respond to how it feels in the moment.
Today’s newsletter breaks down how to use pricing psychology to make your offer feel like a no-brainer:
Why your current pricing structure might be killing conversions
4 psychological principles that shift perceived value
A quick experiment to run with your leads this week
And how to reframe your pricing for max clarity and confidence
Let’s make your “think about it” prospects start saying, “When can we start?”
Exclusive Partner: Uptick
Tariff Costs Are Up. Here’s One Way to Offset Them Instantly.
Shipping fees and tariffs are cutting into margins—so smart e-commerce brands are finding new ways to grow profit without spending more.
With Uptick, you can monetize your order confirmation page by showing high-quality, brand-safe ads from top advertisers like Disney+, HelloFresh, and Apple Music.
Uptick manages everything end-to-end, placing a single ad unit after checkout that blends seamlessly with your existing experience.
How it works:
Brands earn $30K–$60K in profit per 100K orders
No cost, no dev lift, no risk
Seamless experience that works alongside your existing upsells
Pricing that confuses vs. pricing that converts
When you build pricing to explain the offer, things get muddy.
You lose clarity. You lose urgency. You lose the close.
Pricing should be built to sell and to guide the prospect toward a confident “yes.”
Here’s where things usually fall apart:
Leading with numbers before value
Drop a high-ticket price with zero context, and you’ve anchored the prospect in fear.
Overloading with choices
More options = more friction. Without a clear standout, people stall.
Missing contrast between tiers
A good pricing structure creates a “hero” offer that feels like the obvious move.
Forgetting pricing is emotional
Smart buyers still make gut decisions. The way your pricing feels is just as important as what it says.
If your structure doesn’t build confidence and clarity, even the best offer will get brushed off with a polite “I’ll think about it.”
The psychology behind pricing that drives confident decisions
Pricing doesn’t live in a vacuum.
It operates inside a mental framework shaped by emotion, expectation, and comparison.
If your pricing structure isn’t converting, it’s often because the context around the number is off, not the number itself.
The best brands use these 4 psychological cues to reframe perceived value:
Anchoring as perception control
The first number shown, whether it’s a premium tier, competitor comparison, or retail price, shapes how every number after feels.
Anchoring isn’t just about showing a big number first. It’s about engineering a perceived deal.
Framing as context-building
$3,000/month sounds expensive.
But “less than the cost of an entry-level hire” or “$100/day to unlock $X in missed revenue” feels practical.
Strategic framing reduces resistance without changing the price, only the narrative.
Decoy pricing as behavioral nudge
Introducing a “middle” or “premium” tier that exists to guide the choice is a classic behavioral design move.
It removes ambiguity and makes the intended option feel like the smart, safe, and socially acceptable choice.
Loss aversion as motivation amplifier
Prospects are more motivated by what they risk losing than what they could gain.
Effective pricing highlights the cost of inaction.
These are structural tools used to shift the emotional weight of your offer so it lands as the obvious, safe, and strategic decision.
From theory to action: Reframing your pricing for clarity and conversion
You’ve got the psychological principles.
Now it’s time to test how they play out in the real world.
Here’s a simple experiment you can run with prospects or past leads this week:
Create two versions of your pricing deck or proposal
Keep the offer the same, but adjust the presentation.
Version A: Your current layout
Version B: Reframed with a clear anchor, context-based framing, and a defined “best value” tier
Send both versions to 3–5 warm leads
Ask them which feels clearer or more compelling. You’re not asking them to buy, you’re testing for perception.
Track response quality
Are replies faster?
Do they ask fewer questions?
Do they see the value faster?
What you’ll find: the same offer, structured differently, can create two completely different buying experiences.
Once you’ve tested it, implement what works:
Lead with value, not numbers
Build a short narrative before the price to shift their frame of reference.
Position your tiers with intention
Don’t just stack features. Build contrast between options, highlight one as the obvious choice, and eliminate clutter.
Use language that reinforces outcomes
Every label, bullet, and subtitle should tie back to the result they care about. Not just what they get.
The goal is to guide decision-making by reducing cognitive friction and increasing perceived certainty.
surefoot - Your ads are driving traffic, but are your pages turning visitors into buyers?
Every week, the team at surefoot shares real-world A/B test results, proven CRO strategies, and practical insights to help you optimize your website and maximize your conversion rates.
No fluff. No generic advice.
Just actionable takeaways from brands doing $10MM to $200M.
👉️ Sign up now and start converting more shoppers into buyers.
Final Thoughts
If you’re getting ghosted after sharing your price, the offer probably isn’t the issue.
It’s the presentation.
Confusing structures, weak framing, and zero contrast create hesitation, even when the value is clear.
Fix how you show your price, and you’ll fix how people respond to it.
Not with discounts.
Not with more features.
Just better structure.
Start there. The results speak fast.
Want growth that looks like this👇?
 |  |
 |  |
HOW??
We Use Strategies and Systems that Produce Consistent Results.
We’ve helped 100+ brands—from early-stage DTC startups to global brands—scale smarter, grow faster and get profitable. Whether your goal rapid growth, consistency at scale or just to be profitable again, we've built systems and strategies to achieve that for hundreds of brands over the years.
The results? You get reliable and consistent growth without sacrificing your profitability.
» Hire me to scale your DTC Brand «