- Nord Media
- Posts
- 🧠 Your High-Ticket Customers Won’t Stick Around Unless...
🧠 Your High-Ticket Customers Won’t Stick Around Unless...
Retention for premium brands plays by different rules. Here’s how to win.
Kody Nordquist
March 11, 2025
Welcome back to the 77th edition of Nord Media
Before we get started, is there anything specific you want to learn about? Let me know, as always, I appreciate all of you who reply each week and share feedback with me.
Personally, I love indulging in a good cup of coffee. I mean, what entrepreneur doesn’t?
So one day, I finally decided to take the plunge and buy a high-end espresso machine. I check out, drop a few hundred bucks, and wait for my shiny new machine to arrive.
Then what?
Well, I can’t just have the machine. I need the accessories. A proper tamper, a milk frother, maybe some fancy beans to match.
And just like that, I’m back on the brand’s site, adding more to my cart.
This isn’t by accident. This brand designed an experience that keeps customers (me) engaged, spending, and coming back… but too many brands assume that a big first purchase guarantees loyalty.
It doesn’t.
So in this playbook, I'm breaking down:
The biggest mistake high-ticket brands make with retention (and how to fix it)
How to design post-purchase experiences that drive repeat orders
A framework for increasing LTV without discounting or cheapening the brand
Let’s dive in.
🧠 Exclusive Partner: Uptick
Your Order Confirmation Page Is a Hidden Goldmine—Here’s How to Cash In
Most e-commerce brands are leaving money on the table. The smartest ones? They’re turning their order confirmation pages into six- and seven-figure profit centers, effortlessly.
With Uptick, you can monetize your post-purchase experience with premium advertisers like Disney+, HelloFresh, and Apple Music—without disrupting your customer journey.
What makes Uptick different?
Uptick shows premium offers from advertisers like Disney+, HelloFresh, and Apple Music on your order confirmation page
$25K–$40K in profit per 100K orders — at zero cost to you
Seamless setup — live in minutes, fully managed by our team
Your order confirmation page is already getting traffic. It’s time to monetize it.
The Biggest Mistake High-Ticket Brands Make with Retention (And How to Fix It)
Automatic loyalty isn’t guaranteed just because someone drops $300+ on your product.
In fact, without a plan to bring them back, they’ll buy once and disappear. No urgency. No reason to stay engaged.
Here’s how to fix it:
Make the next step obvious
Don’t leave customers wondering what to buy next.
Accessories, refills, or premium upgrades should feel like a natural extension of their purchase.
Build an onboarding experience
A smooth setup makes customers more likely to use (and love) the product.
A welcome email, a quick-start guide, or a short video can go a long way.
Keep the relationship alive
Check in before they check out. Personalized recommendations, helpful content, and post-purchase emails that add value (not just push sales) keep customers engaged.
Create a reason to return
Whether it’s VIP perks, exclusive product drops, or insider access, customers need a compelling why to come back without relying on discounts.
Don’t just hope they return. Give them a reason to.
How to Design Post-Purchase Experiences That Drive Repeat Orders
The sale isn’t the finish line, it’s the starting point. A well-designed post-purchase experience will turn one-time buyers into repeat customers.
Here’s how to do it right:
Make them feel good about their purchase
A thoughtful thank-you email, an order confirmation with personality, or a quick-start guide builds excitement and reinforces value.
Deliver a seamless unboxing experience
High-ticket purchases should feel premium. A well-designed package, a personalized note, or an easy setup process makes customers more likely to engage (and buy again).
Stay in their inbox (the right way)
Send useful emails: tips on getting the most out of their purchase, care instructions, or product pairings. Make it feel like support, not a sales pitch.
Introduce the next step naturally
If they bought a $500 espresso machine, they’ll need premium beans, a grinder, or maintenance tools. Show them what’s next without forcing the sale.
Turn buyers into insiders
Give them VIP access, early product drops, or loyalty perks that make them feel part of something exclusive.
Don’t focus primarily on selling for the post-purchase experience.
Instead then provide them with a logical guide regarding their next purchase.
Looking to simplify growth and build lasting customer relationships? Join Recharge at ChargeX—the must-attend event for DTC brands, eCommerce leaders, and subscription innovators, happening in Los Angeles this May.
This year, we're bringing together some of the most influential voices in the industry, including:
Paris Hilton, CEO of 11:11 Media, Brian Tate, Founder & CEO of Oats Overnight,
Sandeep Chouksey, CTO of Harry’s, Inc.and Durana Elmi, Co-Founder & COO of Cymbiotika. A line up you do not want to miss.
Expect actionable insights, powerful networking, and exclusive strategies to turn one-time buyers into loyal subscribers, increase LTV, and drive sustainable growth.
🔥 What to Expect at ChargeX:
✅ Game-changing insights from top industry leaders
✅ Expert panels and hands-on workshops
✅ Exclusive networking with DTC founders, operators, and executives
✅ Actionable strategies to scale your subscription business
💡 Exclusive Offer: Use code Nord Media for $100 off your ticket!
🎟️ Register now
Don’t miss your chance to connect, learn, and grow with the best in the industry. See you at ChargeX! 🚀.
The Framework for Increasing LTV Without Discounting
Luxury packaging, a well-crafted unboxing experience, and a personal touch (like a handwritten note or welcome email) reinforce the value of their purchase.
↓
Enhance Product Stickiness
Provide setup guides, usage tips, and ongoing education. Show them how to get the most out of their purchase so it becomes part of their routine.
↓
Build a Strong Post-Purchase Funnel
Stay in touch, but with value. Follow up with helpful emails, personalized recommendations, and exclusive content. Make them feel supported, not just sold to.
↓
Create Exclusive Perks & Upsells
Instead of discounts, offer premium add-ons, VIP experiences, or exclusive early access to new products. Position the next purchase as an upgrade, not a bargain.
↓
Encourage Community & Advocacy
Turn customers into brand advocates. A private group, a referral program, or a UGC campaign makes them feel like part of something bigger.
Closing Thoughts
Well, that’s all for today. Hopefully, this gave you some ideas on how to keep customers coming back without resorting to endless discounts.
Meanwhile, I’ll be over here fully committing to my espresso obsession.
The tamper? Ordered.
The milk frother? Already on the way.
At this point, I might as well open a café.
Looking for more of my recommendations? Here’s some other services I personally use and strongly recommend 👇
Superfiliate - Consolidate all of your word of mouth programs (influencer, affiliate, ambassador, referral) into one app while turning every link shared by a creator or customer into a co-branded high converting landing page.
Signup today and get 1 month free simply by mentioning my name when you onboard😎
QRY - Fix what’s holding your paid media back. Spending 7+ figures on paid media but seeing rising CAC, plateauing returns, or stalled growth? QRY helps consumer brands turn media investment into sustained, profitable growth with a full-funnel strategy built for scale. Get a free Blueprint Strategy Session to pinpoint inefficiencies, uncover growth opportunities, and build a smarter media strategy. Spots are limited—secure yours today. >> Get Started Today <<
Aligned Growth - I’ve been working with the team at Aligned Growth for a few months now across several brands I work on. On-top of that they’ve helped HexClad generate over 450M views just last year. If you’re doing over $6M / year and looking to start or improve your influencer & product seeding program. » Learn More «
Goodo Studios - A lot of brands struggle with the creative output needed to continue scaling effectively. This is why a majority of the brands I work with including my own use Goodo Studios to supplement their creative team. Their process is extremely simple and dialed in to ensure they’re able to step into any brand and demonstrate and industry leading level of performance to help you and your brand scale. » Sign Up Today «
Marpipe - It’s time to face it - your DPA doesn’t look good. It’s raw and incomplete. This is hurting your brand and your performance. Marpipe fixes this. The best operators in the world (Ridge, Simple Modern, True Classic) use Marpipe to run 2x better performing DPA. » Get started «
Raleon - Stop wasting time manually building and maintaining customer segments. Raleon's AI-powered segmentation platform automatically creates and updates your customer segments based on real behavior patterns and predictive analytics. Their technology saves brands 10+ hours per month while delivering better results than traditional rule-based approaches. Try it free today (no installation required)
Surefoot - Your ads are driving traffic, but are your pages turning visitors into buyers? Every week, the team at Surefoot shares real-world A/B test results, proven CRO strategies, and practical insights to help you optimize your website and maximize your conversion rates. No fluff. No generic advice. Just actionable takeaways from brands doing $10MM to $200M. 👉️ Sign up now and start converting more shoppers into buyers.
Patrol - is NOT another overlay widget. Instead, it fixes violations at the code level—meaning your store actually becomes more accessible.
Patrol automates what used to be a manual, expensive process of ADA compliance. Using research out of MIT and the latest AI advancements, Patrol detects accessibility issues that traditional overlays miss and fixes them properly.
Get Started Today and save 20% off your first 12 months.
Saral - Managing influencers is a time suck. Finding them, emailing back and forth, tracking what they post, measuring results...
SARAL puts everything in one platform. No more switching between 5 different tools or losing track of conversations with multiple spreadsheets.
It's why brands that value their time (like Obvi, Salud, and Homecourt) use it to run smoother campaigns with better results. Chat with the team → (Let them know I sent you!)